The Pocono Mountains in Pennsylvania is a beloved vacation destination, renowned for its natural beauty, outdoor activities, and scenic views. Whether you’re hiking through lush forests, skiing down snowy slopes, or enjoying the lakeside retreats, the area is filled with wonderful experiences. However, dining out can sometimes come with sticker shock if you end up at some of the more expensive restaurants in the region. While there are many options, some restaurants in the Poconos may not offer the value to match their high prices. Here’s a look at six overpriced restaurants you might want to avoid to keep your dining experience as enjoyable and budget-friendly as possible.
1. The Frogtown Chophouse
The Frogtown Chophouse is a popular destination for steak and seafood lovers in the Poconos. Offering an upscale dining atmosphere, the restaurant serves high-quality dishes, including signature steaks, seafood platters, and delectable sides. Despite the praises, several guests have voiced concerns over the restaurant’s pricing, which is particularly steep for the portion sizes provided.
According to reviews on TripAdvisor, guests frequently mention that while the food is well-prepared, the prices for entrees, such as the prime rib or lobster, feel inflated compared to other local options. For instance, a steak dinner can easily exceed $50, and that’s before appetizers, sides, or drinks are considered. While the ambiance and service are solid, many feel that the high cost isn’t fully justified by the food’s quality or portion size.
2. Oyster Seafood and Steakhouse
Oyster is another fine dining establishment in the Pocono region, specializing in seafood and steak dishes. Located at the Stroudsmoor Country Inn, it has garnered attention for its high-end offerings and fresh seafood. However, many diners feel that Oyster’s pricing falls on the extreme side, particularly for dishes that don’t seem exceptional.
Several customer reviews on platforms like Yelp and TripAdvisor point out that the prices for basic items, such as a seafood platter or oysters, are disproportionately high. Even though the restaurant positions itself as a luxurious dining experience, the food’s taste and portion sizes often leave guests feeling that they haven’t received full value for their money.
3. Stone Bar Inn
Stone Bar Inn is a well-known establishment in Long Pond, Pennsylvania. The restaurant offers an elegant atmosphere with an eclectic menu featuring American classics, seafood, and steaks. Despite its reputation, Stone Bar Inn has received feedback that the pricing, especially for its more signature dishes, doesn’t match the overall experience.
Customers report that dishes like filet mignon and blackened Mahi are undoubtedly flavorful, but the portion sizes are often smaller than expected, and the prices are higher than comparable dishes at other fine dining spots in the region. One reviewer on TripAdvisor mentioned that they spent over $80 for two people and still left feeling hungry. If you’re searching for upscale dining, Stone Bar Inn delivers on ambiance but may not offer the best bang for your buck.
4. Rustic Kitchen Bistro & Bar
Rustic Kitchen Bistro & Bar is celebrated for its unique layout and live cooking shows. The restaurant is spacious, with four different dining areas, and offers an array of Italian and American dishes. Its diverse menu includes gourmet pizzas, steaks, and seafood, alongside a variety of unique cocktails. However, while the entertainment factor is high, many visitors feel the pricing is disproportionately high for the dishes served.
Diners have commented that the quality of food doesn’t always justify the cost, especially when considering its high-end prices. A typical meal at Rustic Kitchen can set you back significantly, especially if you’re enjoying the full show experience alongside dinner. While the entertainment adds a special touch, if you’re purely looking for food quality, there are other restaurants in the Poconos that might provide a better balance between price and value.
5. Garlic Restaurant & Bar
Garlic Restaurant & Bar is a trendy spot in the Poconos known for its farm-to-table cuisine. The restaurant’s menu is entirely gluten-free, making it a unique destination for people with dietary restrictions. The dishes focus on fresh, locally sourced ingredients, and the menu offers a blend of American and international dishes. Despite these positive aspects, Garlic’s prices are notably higher than the average restaurant in the area.
Several patrons have expressed disappointment over the high costs, especially for simple dishes like steaks or seafood. While the restaurant aims to cater to a more refined palate with its specialized menu, the pricing leaves many guests questioning whether the cost is worth it. If you’re seeking a gluten-free dining experience, Garlic is one of the few options in the region, but it’s important to be prepared for a hefty bill.
6. Louie’s Prime Steak House
Louie’s Prime Steak House is a popular destination for steak lovers in Lake Harmony, Pennsylvania. It offers a classic steakhouse experience with a wide range of cuts and accompaniments, along with an extensive wine list. However, Louie’s Prime is often criticized for its pricing, which is considered steep even by steakhouse standards.
Diners have reported that while the steaks are well-prepared and the wine list is extensive, the overall experience doesn’t always justify the cost. The restaurant’s upscale pricing may be expected for a steakhouse, but for visitors to the Poconos, where there are numerous other dining options, Louie’s Prime doesn’t necessarily offer the best value for money
Final Thoughts
Dining out in the Pocono Mountains can be a memorable part of your visit, but it’s important to choose restaurants that offer both quality and value. The six restaurants mentioned above are known for their upscale menus, but many diners have reported that the prices don’t always match the food and service provided. If you’re planning a trip to the Poconos, consider exploring some of the other local gems that offer delicious food without the steep price tags.
For those seeking high-quality meals without breaking the bank, options like Smuggler’s Cove for seafood or Van Guilder’s Jubilee Restaurant for a family-friendly dining experience can provide excellent alternatives(
Mountain Top Lodge 2024). Moreover, local favorites like Stone Row Pub and Eatery offer a fresh take on American cuisine without the exorbitant prices(
Dining in the Pocono Mountains doesn’t have to be an overpriced affair. With some careful selection, you can enjoy a wonderful meal without overspending. Avoiding the high-cost traps of certain fine dining establishments ensures you’ll leave with both a full stomach and your wallet intact.
